Dear Marion,
You could ask a question for me to veterans who have been in Italy?
I love the m1 helmets and collect them, but there is a disagreement.
Veterans remember if they or their companions have never had a m1 front seam swivel bail in Italy in '44 '45?
Many of my friends here claim that there were never. Were all fixed bail!
Thank you very much,
Enrico
Enrico sent me a private PM. I have emailed this question to every WWII vet on my list. Let's see what transpires this time around. Happy to assist.
Marion J Chard
Proud Daughter of Walter 'Monday' Poniedzialek
540th Combat Engineer - H&S Company
Front seam, swivel bale helmets appeared around September 1944 in the ETO (maybe even sooner).
I guess the same goes for the MTO.
New units and new reinforcements to the units already in the MTO must have worn those types already.
Rear seam, swivel bale helmets were never worn in WWII as far as I know.
Hope this helps.
Erwin
704th Tank Destroyer Battalion
https://ardennes-breakthrough-association.com/
I remembered this link on our main site:
He has a lot of photos and info on his site. You can also contact him directly Enrico. I'm sure he could answer all your questions.
Marion J Chard
Proud Daughter of Walter 'Monday' Poniedzialek
540th Combat Engineer - H&S Company
Here's a great page on another site:
Hey Jeeps -I found this on that page:
LATE WAR M-1 HELMET SHELLS
M-1 Helmet (1944 - 1945)
Due to the profound problem of the brightness of the stainless steel rims, in May of 1944 the Army Service Forces requested that the problem be corrected. Until that point, other options to solve the problem had been implemented such as the use of sandblasting and utility tape, but these both were unsatisfactory.
Distinguishing features
In October 1944 the rim material changed from stainless to the same steel that the helmets were made from (Hadfield Maganese). Evidently, for some unknown reason, at the same time, the weld seam of the rim also migrated to the rear.
Note: I personally have found numerous rear seam WWII era shells with stainless steel rims, suggesting the existing stocks of stainless rims must have been used up even after the change was put in place
Marion J Chard
Proud Daughter of Walter 'Monday' Poniedzialek
540th Combat Engineer - H&S Company
Thanks a lot for all the answers, I have always maintained, that certainly in the Gothic Line, were present m1 swivel bail, but my friends have always closed my mouth with phrases like "that's impossible!" ![]()
Precisely for this reason I hoped in the memories of some veterans to prove that it is not impossible, on the contrary!
I have repeatedly tried to explain to them that the production of swivel bale, front seam i'ts started in September 1944 (if I remember correctly for a month) but it seemed to speak with the gods of WWII! ![]()
Thanks again I will study all this stuff!
Add:
For dating I was referring to this site, has a very interesting list! http://www.hardscrabblefarm.com/ww2/dating_m1.htm
Grandson of Private Pedro Pedrini, 14th Infantry Regiment, "Pinerolo" Brigade.
Transferred to 3rd Regiment Telegraph Engineer During WW I
Ah, you now have some "ammunition" in your belt!
Knowledge IS power!!!
So glad we were able to help you with your question today. This is fun!
BTW, my nickname on the forum is M1!
Marion J Chard
Proud Daughter of Walter 'Monday' Poniedzialek
540th Combat Engineer - H&S Company
Never saw the swivel bail in Italy in my outfit. Russ Weiskircher
Marion J Chard
Proud Daughter of Walter 'Monday' Poniedzialek
540th Combat Engineer - H&S Company
Please not the difference;
Rear seam, fix bale helmets; used from August - September 1944 ETO (MTO maybe even a little later);
and
Rear seam, swivel bale helmets; in my opinion never used in WWII, only from around August - September 1945 (or even later).
What me personally is concerned;
If I want to make a D-Day display, I'd go for a front seam, fix bale helmet.
If I want a The Bulge display, I might go for a front seam, swivel bale helmet but I would prefer a front seam, fix bale helmet.
And if I would go for a Germany 1945 display, I might go for a front seam, swivel bale helmet.
In either case, I don't think it would have mattered to the GI what type his helmet was.
As long as it kept his head safe!
Erwin
704th Tank Destroyer Battalion
https://ardennes-breakthrough-association.com/
Please not the difference;
Rear seam, fix bale helmets; used from August - September 1944 ETO (MTO maybe even a little later);
Rear seam, fixed bail? ![]()
I have not ever heard and I've never seen anyone either in photo, nor for sale ...
You got some pictures?
Grandson of Private Pedro Pedrini, 14th Infantry Regiment, "Pinerolo" Brigade.
Transferred to 3rd Regiment Telegraph Engineer During WW I
In either case, I don't think it would have mattered to the GI what type his helmet was.As long as it kept his head safe!
Erwin
Thank You Erwin! My sentiments exactly. I started collecting WWII items only 5 years ago and I still don't understand how some people will pay such outrageous prices for helmets and etc. unless they were cursed with having too much money ![]()
Dogdaddy 1
you're right, prices have risen a lot, but I think to those who collect German helmets ...
In Italy, was sold a German paratrooper helmet at € 12,000 about $ 16,500 ... wow have the value of a large diamond (this is really crazy). ![]()
![]()
I have 3 m1 fixed bail, one of a lieutenant, one of MP of the Texas Division and one with the name and serial number of an unlucky soldier who killed in action in France (when I bought it I did not know, I later found this bad info from the serial number...) but I did not spend so much for any of the three! And I would not spend so ever!
Grandson of Private Pedro Pedrini, 14th Infantry Regiment, "Pinerolo" Brigade.
Transferred to 3rd Regiment Telegraph Engineer During WW I
Rear seam, fixed bail?
I have not ever heard and I've never seen anyone either in photo, nor for sale ...
You got some pictures?
I'm so sorry, I meant front seam, swivel bale helmets.
That should teach me not to type things so late at night. ![]()
Erwin
704th Tank Destroyer Battalion
https://ardennes-breakthrough-association.com/
I'm so sorry, I meant front seam, swivel bale helmets.
That should teach me not to type things so late at night.
Erwin
hahaha no problem, indeed I had hoped it was a rare variant so I immediately start looking for one on sale! ![]()
Grandson of Private Pedro Pedrini, 14th Infantry Regiment, "Pinerolo" Brigade.
Transferred to 3rd Regiment Telegraph Engineer During WW I
A friend told me that several m1 front seam swivel bail were found, already in houses and under ground in the areas of the Futa Pass!
This partly answers my question, but as I said there is nothing more secure than the memory of a veteran! ![]()
Grandson of Private Pedro Pedrini, 14th Infantry Regiment, "Pinerolo" Brigade.
Transferred to 3rd Regiment Telegraph Engineer During WW I